Amazing pizza. Tastes like it’s homemade. Always feel like I get good value from here.

Gonna be dreaming about the house creamy garlic dip tonight

So I frequently go to the shelburne location and stumbled across thos location here in orangeville and am wondering how it could be the same johnnys pizza when its soo subpar to the shelburne one the slice was way smaller and quality is nowhere near the same shelburne lication is definitely 5 stars orangeville is not even 2 stars

The Service is Awesome.
Pizza is not greasy on the bottom like other places are.
Prices are Good.
If you order more items on your pizza you pay more for it.
I fine Johnny's Pizza's are bigger in sizes then other places.
Johnny's Pizza Sauce is the only one I can eat that doesn't upset my stomach.

I have a friend who has Everything on his Pizza.
Johnny's Pizza in Shelburne is the only one who will make it for him. Where the other Pizza Shop Won't.

Best pizza by far

Good deals, and big slices

Best Pizza Ever Big Slices, Best Meatlovers Pizza I've Ever Had And Always Fresh. Also Their Chicken Wings Are Good.
Workers Are Very Nice. 10/10

Very nice preparation and very friendly staff

(Translated by Google) Delicious pizza

(Original)
Delicius pizza

Best service and best pizza

Great pizza.

Best pizza in Shelburne!!!
(Hard to get good parking but worth it)

real nice

Best pizza in town! Only spot to go

Good

Tasty hot pizza what more can you ask for?

If I order Pizza in town, its definitely Johnnys. I have never had a bad experience with them. Always made fresh to order. If I crave pizza I know who to call. Staff have always been delightful. Ive gone in and placed an order late night just before they closed after my shift of dealing with people all day and they were still welcoming. I highly recommend them. Theyve had amazing pizza ever since I was kid.

Never get enough! The best panzeroti you can have there is no comparison I've had 40 panzies and they can't come close you want authentic panzeroti goto Johnny's pizza the never disappointed

The best pizza and wings!

THE BEST PIZZA AND WINGS

Great pizza, good price, wish the Orangeville location tasted as good as this

Old school excellence. Not a fancy place. Their focus is on the best quality ingredients, no short cuts or fillers.
Outstanding pizza at a reasonable price.

Best real pizza in town by far. beats all that factory made pizza that is taking over.

Keep it up guys.

Always great for a quick hearty slice of pizza!

was in shelburne to visit a friend and grabbed pizza from here as it was closest to his house. The only problem I have with this place is thats its not closest to my house... by a long ways.. this place is amazing.. its got the perfect pizzeria vibe and the pizza was so good. pricing is super fair. why would you go anywhere else?!?!

Bravo Johnny's Pizza.. Bravo. Cant wait til im back next to visit

We have been going to Johnnys once a week for 4 years and no complaints.
Staff is always friendly.

Best pizza in town. Must try

Best pizza in town....and biggest. 1 slice is a whole meal....lots of toppings and fresh.

Went to this place to try the pizza. Very happy that the lady upsold me from a medium to a large as it was cheaper. Pizza was good. Like reading the history about the place on the wall

Fantastic slice shop. Highly recommended.

Last few pizzas I got have the toppings under the cheese, they use to put the toppings on top, I like them on the top so they crisp up, but its still a delicious pie

THIS IS DELICIOUS BEST PIZZA EVER

My kids love their $5 slice deal!

Great pizza!

Utterly delicious vegetable pizza. Quiet and clean atmosphere. The staff is very generous and convincing. Loved the pizza.

My daughter loves her "Johnnys Cheese Pizza" The only pizza she wants

Amazing Food, Amazing Service, Amazing Atmosphere, 5 Stars

Best pizza around!

Best pizza around. Been going to Johnnys since I was a kid in the 90's. They always supported the community and have never sacrificed quality after all these years. Highly recommend these guys to anyone passing through Shelburne.

Great pizza

Best place to get a Slice!

Great pizza. If your not getting your pizza here You are missing out. This is amazing pizza , They are a staple in Shelburne and use the best Fresh ingredients available really nice people too.

My family and I saw a nice , cozy old Italian restaurant on our way back from sauble beach late evening. We didnt waste a second before we rushed in and ordered the biggest XL pizza we had ever seen along with some wings. The pictures on the wall, the nice lady at the front , and the owner all give off rich history and amazing vibes.Pizza was exquisite , fresh ingredients and tomato sauce with some goooooood cheese. After we made a mess with plates and ate everything, we realized the store was closed for dine-in an hour before we even placed the order on a SUNDAY . Most places would have physically kicked us out and I wouldnt blame them but it was only the staffs and the owners generosity and kindness that allowed us to stay there and eat after closing. Truly something my family and I wont forget. In a world thats always rushing and chasing , we were met with a place of grace and those days that remind you the good old times. Thank you Johnny for the memorable night. GO GET THEIR PIZZA NOW

The slices were huge and delicious! We grabbed a pizza and some meals for a picnic in the park with the kids on the drive home from the cottage and I was a bit early to pick it up. They were doing a very brisk 'pizza by the slice' business and I can see why!

Stopped in here for a quick slice. Its on the main street in town. Always love going to independent shops like this as opposed to the big chains. They make a really good slice of pizza crispy crust fluffy not too spicy sauce and just the right amount of cheese and pepperoni. Probably one of the better pizza places Ive been to in a long, long time. Wish I lived closer if Im ever in the area Ill definitely be back.

Always great pizza at a reasonable price.

Best panzerotti ever, also luv the hot chicken wings, Thanks Johnny's Pizza Shelburne.

1st time there today....extremely tasty!
Very impressed, will definitely stop in when I drive thought that town !

Great pizza service is even more tech owner is very nice and has really cool stories

Owner is very kind and has great stories. The food is amazing and full of flavour.

Wonderfully crafted pizza. Hearty and delicious!

honestly there is no other pizza option I would go with in shelburne. The quality is always amazing, the staff is always delightful. Have never had an issue with ordering from them. They are my do to pizza place, I suggest it to everyone ordering pizza in and out of town!

Johnny's Pizza is the best pizza you will ever have the pleasure of eating!
It starts with the hand made dough. Then is special tomato sauce followed by the best toppings ever. Enjoy!!

Fantastic pizza. We are from out of town and every time we come through Shelburne we’ll order . Always hot, lots of toppings and friendly service.

Best Pizza around .

Best pizza

Best Pizzeria In Shelburne!!!!

Johnny's is by far the best pizza in a 100km radius.

Hidden gem… the pizza is phenomenal !!

Johnny is so skibidi!!! ????????

Best pizza in town by far…however they don’t appear to have a “steady” delivery service and may be missing out on $$ from competitors.

This place is amazing! Gigantic slices that taste great!

????????????

Best pizza

Absolutely stupendous pizza, clearly the best I've ever had, hands down!!

Best pizza in the area , always fresh ingredients and plenty of them.
Always made the way you want it .
Very fair prices

it was soooooo good

This place is amazing the food is awesome you get way more than you can eat your money's worth I recommend this place to everyone

Best in Shelburne

Awesome pizza best in the area

Amazing food and service! Great small town family style pizza shop!

Always good

I wish we came here sooner when we moved here! Plentiful toppings, great service, reliably delicious. Best pizza in town by FAR!

The best pizza

Good pizza.

This is the best pizza you will ever taste....each and every time!!

excellent food

When I order extra cheese, these guys are the only ones who listen. Amazing every time!

The best pizza!

Great service, great pizza!!

Best pizza for sure in town!

Best pizza and wings hands down in shelburne ty Kevin and Jenn

Top notch pizza great store owners a pleasure everytime I go in thnx Sam and Mrs Sam lol

have to stop by this spot and try their pizza if you're a pizza lover! from their dough to their sauce and fresh ingredients it never fails to satisfy.

best pizza in town

Best cheese pizza I've ever had.

Excellent pizza the best around by far the best crust and quality ingredients make Johnnys the top.

Great food an affordable price

JONNY'S SHELBURNE!! BEST PIE IN DUFFERIN COUNTY!! BEEN ENJOY IT FOR YEARS....AND WILL FOR MANY MORE...KEEP UP THE GOOD WORK SAM AND STAFF!

fabulous love there pizza

Best Pizza around.

Great place love pizza l will go again

Easily the best pizza in Shelburne...if not in all of Dufferin County.

– Ethan Praxis

Absolutely LOVE Johhny's Pizza!!! Best pizza in Dufferin County, hands down. Tastes just like the great pizzas that were served up back in the 1970's in Toronto. Great sauce, crust, and toppings, and tons of pizza for the cost. Job well done!!

Always awesome pizza they have the biggest slices I have ever had!

Best

Their pizza is delicious! Customer service is awesome!

Johnny's Pizza is a classic in Shelburne for years. Simple, delicious and BIG pizzas, definitely my fave in town.

I have been eating their pizza for 40+ years. From Pizza Days at C.H.E.S. to Friday night deliveries during a pandemic, it’s always great!

Best pizza around

Best pizza ever, one of our overall favorites

Pizza was good but the wings are even better

Very delicious pizza, the slices are huge. The wings tasted amazing. Definitely best pizza in Town.

They make great pizza

Great quick sub! Will definitely be returning next time Im in town.

Great pizza, very friendly service!

Same great pizza as always Fast and friendly service as well.

great pizza

Great pizza

Best Pizza

First time good pizza great value will be back

Fantastic pies. Huge pies.

Best pizza in town

I love the wings here ordering them now

Always great food

Best pizza!!!!

Love going there. Their pizza is great. Our son loves the garlic pizza. Very fresh amd convenient

(Translated by Google) Super, Perfect

(Original)
Super, Perfect

I ordered a panzarotto. Best dough in Ontario! Excellent food, ingredients were fresh and tasty, friendly service

Excellent pizza

Been my family's go to pizza place for years now! Always a pleasure!

Best Pizza. Best Service.

Thick crust, plenty of toppings, and large portions. Inexpensive. A town fixture.

Grabbed a a slice of Pizza driving through there one day, and was probably one of the best tasting Ive had in a long while.

Best pizza in Shelburne! Delicious!

Best pie and price

The best pizza North of the city

Excellent pizza !

Best pizza in Ontario

Made a quick stop here to grab a bite on our way north, great pizza and quick service.

Best pizza in shelburne!

Excellent and fresh pizza, friendly staff

Great local Pizza spot! Just as good as the city! Hidden Gem

Great pizza

Great prices and great slices. You can feed two kids and yourself off of two slices. Staff is always super friendly.

Fabulous! Only complaint is no cheddar cheese! Still incredible.

Amazing Chicken Wings

The best pizza in the north!!!

Consistentlying terrific

My favorite pizza, great service.

Some of the best pizza I have ever had

Decent place to grab a pizza, if you're out in Shelbourne

Sooooo good

Huge pizza slices. Cheap price. Best pizza in town.

10/10

Great pizza and love they help the town

The pizza is good I can't lie but the service.....where's da smile and lose the attitude

Great tasting pizza every time! Fresh ingredients. Open for pick up only. Easy online order.

Always awesome...will add 15min to a 2 and a half hour drive to get the pizza...the two of us eat half on the way home and the rest for lunch the next day!

Hearing my son and his friend polish off most of a large pepperoni pizza on the drive back to Centre Wellington, going on and on about how much better it was then the pizza they normally have at home was pretty funny. Had a couple of slices and they were right. If it is good enough for the cast of Schitt's Creek, it definitely good enough for me! Could we get a Johnny's in Fergus or Elora?

This is our favorite place to make a stop coming back to GTA by HWY10 when visiting places north of Shelburne. The pizza at this place first impresses you with the size of a slice and then with a rich, juicy and full of flavor taste. If highly recommend to stop by if you like pizza!

The best pizza ever

Always great pizza. Live the thin crust best.

Best Pizza I ever had a must try!

I love pizza in...and around my mouth

Great Pizza. Great value.

Best panzoroties on the planet????

This is really good
Good Pizza ???? ????

Love Johnny's pizza in Shelburne!! Best pizza around!

I love the pizza. Its delicious and I love the size you get for the price! :)

Great Pizza. No need to ask for extra cheese it already is loaded. Try adding garlic butter as well as sauce. It taste delicious. Staff are always friendly.

Our family always stops in for a Johnny's pizza dinner on our way to our cottage. Thanks for making such great tasting pizza!

Biggest best pizza around

Excellent pizza.

Best pizza ever!

Great pizza and crust! Service is friendly, quality is constant. So much better than any pizza around.

The best pizza I've ever had. True

Best pizza ever!

the best in town.any town

Great pizza

Ordered a panzarotto. Best dough in Ontario! Good service.

always so good

Best pizza in Ontario, mho. ... Eric

amazing pizza and service is perfect

The best pizza ever----bar none! Ate it 18years straight every single day and look forward to my next bite when I can get it even to this day 25yrs later. Great work Sammy, love Dayo

Best pizza in town! Walk in and you're greeted by friendly staff. The slices are huge and you can tell the ingredients are fresh and good quality. Also delivery is quick. This is my new favourite spot in town!

Best pizza in town.

Very tasty and very well done pizzas!

This pizzeria is the best hands down for miles around. I will never eat pizza at any other restaurant again! Love you Jonny's!

it the best pizza ive had well in Shelburne

Best and biggest pizza's in town

Best pizza ever

Always delicious!!

The best pizza ever

Longevity of the shop speaks for itself ......simply the best pizza, very well priced, generous sizes and loads of toppings!! The garlic fingers & wings are delicious!! Will never buy from pizza chains again!!

Since moving to Shelburne we have tried a variety of pizza places and we're not pleased. Then we tried Jonnnys and that was it, we were hocked. There food is pleasantly tasty and u get a descent portion. Since that first experience we have not gone anywhere else. The employees are great and very helpful if needed. So give it a try u won't disappointed.

Always fresh and the best!! Can't eat pizza anywhere else.

Be sure to watch us on Comfort Foods!!
https://youtu.be/mQTZhOmaT70

Great pizza. Huge slices. Takes me back to my childhood.

Best Pizza in Shelburne

Great pizza!

I want to have the love with the hot women that work in johnnys, they are always so sweaty me love the sweaty big bumb johnny girls :)

there pizza are great

Best pizza my family and I have ever had anywhere.

Best pizza in dufferin county

It'as amazing indeed it the best pizza from rambally family

Excellent Panzos !!! Thanks for making them again. We enjoy them.

Best Pizza in town

Pizza is fantastic! Your traditional Italian Pizza. If only they made veal, meatball and chicken sandwiches that would be a bonus.

Best pizza in town. Wait can be long as they are usually very busy!

Pretty good for a small town pizza joint. I found that the smaller pizzas tend to be better then the larger ones in terms of taste,etc for whatever reason.
Wings here aren't bad but pretty good hot sauce so it evens out. It can be a little bit of a wait but worth it for pick up rather then delivery

Johnnys Pizza has the best pizza

Best pizza guaranteed,

Great pizza

This pizza is double the size and less expensive and way better then other ones, win,win,win in my eyes

Awesome pizza

The best pizza I town

Great thick crust pizza and amazing service.

amazing

The pizza is amazing whooohooo

Johnnys Pizza never ceases to satisfy mine and my families needs. Their pizza is great, flavourful and their thin crust is the best.